Gilroy's Pages

on UBIDUBIUM.NET

Concert by Marc Cohn
2003 October 16
Joe's Pub, Manhattan, NYC
=-=
Playlist    
Song From Album comments
"From The Station" The Rainy Season  
"Ghost Train" Marc Cohn The guitarist -- Shane Fontaine -- did an unbelievable job with this. The liquid notes he poured over the stage set exactly the not-quite-awake tone of the song and turned a potentially saccharine ballad into a haunting memory.
"Perfect Love" Marc Cohn Although this song is all flowers and niceness, it's never been a favorite of mine. It seems a little too programmed to be a hit at weddings everywhere. Also, Shawn Fontaine proves that, while he's got serious game with a guitar, his voice really is no substitute for James Taylor -- the only thing, IMHO, that makes this song work on the studio album.
"Don't Talk to Her At Night" The Rainy Season This is one of my favorites from The Rainy Season, so I thoroughly enjoyed it. Like "Ghost Train", Mark and Shawn really took advantage of the free-form of a live concert to punch it up a notch.
"Three Steps Down" (?) forthcoming Marc said that Roseanne Cash recently did a good cover of this, but I'd never heard of it.
"If I Were an Angel" forthcoming This song will, when it's released, help prove again why Marc Cohn is perhaps the greatest lyricist in recent memory. He extends a metaphor far, far past what a lesser writer could pull off, and yet it never cracks or crumbles. Whenever the next album comes out, I would buy it for this song alone.
"29 Ways" Marc Cohn I will admit to being one of the few Cohn fans, apparently, who can take or leave this song from the debut album. However, in concert, it is always one of my favorite tunes. For one thing, this is usually the song where Marc finally invites the audience to participate completely. Second, he brings to it a playfulness that, IMHO, is lacking in the studio version.
"The Rainy Season" The Rainy Season This is another song that I feel comes across much more strongly live than in the studio. (Although, I have to admit, as I replayed The Rainy Season to get ready for this show, this one began to grow on me anew.)
"She's Becoming Gold" The Rainy Season This is my all-time and hands-down favorite Marc Cohn song. On the album it's astounding. In concert it was very nearly a religious experience. I am staggered by how sharply Marc conveys the wistfulness and edginess of the piece's subject -- but every time I listen to it, somehow, it strikes me as extremely hopeful.
"Walking in Memphis" Marc Cohn How could anyone not like Marc's breakout hit and signature piece? It's another song where he clearly is simply having fun being a musician. He also pulls the audience in, too, and gets everyone doing the background vocals. At every show I've been to, this is the song where he unlimbers his patented "Let's vocalize some chatter" style ("Can I have a little more monitor, please" sung as a lyric, for example.) It's a song he clearly intends to get the house rocking and he is not disappointed.
"Let Me Be Your Witness" (?) forthcoming Again, if the new album had only this song on it, I'd probably buy it. It's about the other side of relationships -- our need to be the witness and the wall for our loved ones, to be the safe harbor in an unsafe world. Sweet without being sappy and defiant without being dull, it's an athem for anyone who's been the shoulder to cry on.
"Dig Down Deep" Marc Cohn Perhaps the most crowd-pleasing song (and certainly the most-oft-requested tonight), this one got everyone to their feet. It's probably a stamp of Marc's professionalism that, after performing this hundreds of times, he can still manage the little quaver ("We could talk -- we could talk for a while") that so perfectly encapsulates the nervous games at the start of relationships. Another one where, even if he wanted to, he couldn't keep the audience out -- and one where he doesn't even try.
"Silver Thunderbird" Marc Cohn My dad never owned a silver Thunderbird -- or indeed any cool car -- but every time I hear this, I feel closer to him. The song captures, for me, all the hope and loss and pride that form the tangled skein of my memories of my father. That's pretty amazing since the content has no direct relevance -- and again shows why Marc ranks as one of the great storytellers. The song is exact and personal -- and trancendant and universal. In concert this becomes even more apparent, as Marc transforms the family car into a touchstone and an altar.
"One Safe Place" (?) forthcoming This was the fourth time Marc unvieled a hint of what is coming. It's sort of unfair, because it makes me very antsy that he release the album soon. Judging from the other albums, I'm going to predict this will close out the new one, as it closed out the show: Soft and almost spiritual, it embodies the mix of world-weariness and hope that is Marc Cohn's trademark. He's clearly a man on a journey to a place he knows only dimly, and we're clearly fellow travellers with him.
General Comments
 
There were two things that immediately spring to notice: First, Marc played no fewer than four new songs, all of them promised on his next album. Alas, no date as to when that might hit the stores. He thanked the audience for its wild applause when he mentioned a forthcoming album and commended us on our patience: It's been over five years since Burning the Daze.
 
That brings up the second and odder note: Of the fourteen songs Marc played, including two encores, not a single one was from Burning the Daze. He gave no explanation for this nor even a hint that he noticed. I suppose it could have been unintentional. But really -- does no song from the third album outperform any from the second? "Lost You in the Canyon", for example, or "Girl of Mysterious Sorrow" seem to my ear to outplay "The Station" or "Perfect Love". It was somewhat jarring to realize that Burning the Daze had no place in the playlist. At the very least, I would have thought that -- seeing as the show happened in lower Manhattan -- a local-color version of "Ellis Island" would have been a propos.